--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      name:  <unnamed>
       log:  C:\Users\mitch\Dropbox\BLW\POP\Searching for a Bright Line\Replication Materials\Logs/appen
> dix.log
  log type:  text
 opened on:   4 Dec 2018, 20:46:47

. 
. numlabel, add

. 
. tab wave 

       wave |      Freq.     Percent        Cum.
------------+-----------------------------------
          3 |      3,000       33.33       33.33
          4 |      2,000       22.22       55.56
          5 |      2,000       22.22       77.78
          6 |      2,000       22.22      100.00
------------+-----------------------------------
      Total |      9,000      100.00

. sort wave

. 
. 
. recode perf_misconduct-perf_investigations (1=0) (2=0) (3=1) (4=1) (5=.)
(perf_misconduct: 4063 changes made)
(perf_private_gain: 4065 changes made)
(perf_monitor_opponents: 4007 changes made)
(perf_equal_rights: 4028 changes made)
(perf_journalists: 4063 changes made)
(perf_private_violence: 4070 changes made)
(perf_free_speech: 4041 changes made)
(perf_patriotism: 4003 changes made)
(perf_foreign: 4019 changes made)
(perf_ban_ideology: 4054 changes made)
(perf_voting_rights: 4032 changes made)
(perf_votes_impact: 3980 changes made)
(perf_election_fraud: 4092 changes made)
(perf_expand_executive: 4046 changes made)
(perf_legislature_check: 4086 changes made)
(perf_judiciary_check: 4063 changes made)
(perf_judicial_ind: 3976 changes made)
(perf_participation: 3929 changes made)
(perf_funds_transparent: 3960 changes made)
(perf_contributions: 4042 changes made)
(perf_opinions: 4023 changes made)
(perf_districts: 3997 changes made)
(perf_common_und: 4001 changes made)
(perf_compromise: 3959 changes made)
(perf_candidates_disclose: 4025 changes made)
(perf_protest: 4074 changes made)
(perf_investigations: 4052 changes made)

. label value perf_misconduct-perf_investigations statementlabel

. 
. recode imp_misconduct-imp_investigations (0=0) (1=0) (2=1) (3=1) 
(imp_misconduct: 956 changes made)
(imp_private_gain: 917 changes made)
(imp_monitor_opponents: 925 changes made)
(imp_equal_rights: 952 changes made)
(imp_journalists: 896 changes made)
(imp_private_violence: 849 changes made)
(imp_free_speech: 934 changes made)
(imp_patriotism: 832 changes made)
(imp_foreign_influence: 919 changes made)
(imp_ban_ideology: 945 changes made)
(imp_voting_rights: 974 changes made)
(imp_votes_impact: 928 changes made)
(imp_election_fraud: 974 changes made)
(imp_expand_executive: 938 changes made)
(imp_legislature_check: 928 changes made)
(imp_judiciary_check: 930 changes made)
(imp_judicial_ind: 920 changes made)
(imp_participation: 910 changes made)
(imp_funds_transparent: 898 changes made)
(imp_contributions: 835 changes made)
(imp_opinions: 901 changes made)
(imp_districts: 891 changes made)
(imp_common_und: 921 changes made)
(imp_compromise: 841 changes made)
(imp_candidates_disclose: 932 changes made)
(imp_protest: 943 changes made)
(imp_investigations: 950 changes made)

. label value imp_misconduct-imp_investigations statementlabel  

. 
. gen trump = approve_trmp
(47 missing values generated)

. recode trump (2 = 1) (3 = 0) (4 = 0) (8 = .) (9 = .)
(trump: 7115 changes made)

. label define trumpLabel 0 "Not approve Trump" 1 "Approve Trump"

. label value trump trumpLabel

. 
. 
. 
. * PUBLIC IMPORTANCE
. tabstat ///
> imp_election_fraud  imp_protest  imp_equal_rights  imp_journalists  imp_monitor_opponents  imp_free_sp
> eech  imp_voting_rights  ///
> imp_investigations  imp_opinions  imp_private_violence  imp_judicial_ind  imp_misconduct  imp_ban_ideo
> logy  imp_legislature_check  ///
> imp_judiciary_check  imp_expand_executive  imp_candidates_disclose  imp_votes_impact  imp_foreign_infl
> uence  imp_districts  ///
> imp_private_gain  imp_funds_transparent  imp_contributions  imp_common_und  imp_participation  imp_com
> promise  imp_patriotism  ///
>  if wave==3 [aw=weight], format(%8.2f) col(statistics) la(25) var(25)

                 variable |      mean
--------------------------+----------
       imp_election_fraud |      0.90
              imp_protest |      0.82
         imp_equal_rights |      0.85
          imp_journalists |      0.73
    imp_monitor_opponents |      0.80
          imp_free_speech |      0.79
        imp_voting_rights |      0.89
       imp_investigations |      0.84
             imp_opinions |      0.83
     imp_private_violence |      0.68
         imp_judicial_ind |      0.82
           imp_misconduct |      0.84
         imp_ban_ideology |      0.79
    imp_legislature_check |      0.79
      imp_judiciary_check |      0.77
     imp_expand_executive |      0.83
  imp_candidates_disclose |      0.84
         imp_votes_impact |      0.82
    imp_foreign_influence |      0.83
            imp_districts |      0.73
         imp_private_gain |      0.81
    imp_funds_transparent |      0.72
        imp_contributions |      0.70
           imp_common_und |      0.75
        imp_participation |      0.74
           imp_compromise |      0.59
           imp_patriotism |      0.53
-------------------------------------

. 
. * PUBLIC PERFORMANCE
. tabstat ///
> perf_election_fraud  perf_protest  perf_equal_rights  perf_journalists  perf_monitor_opponents  perf_f
> ree_speech  perf_voting_rights  ///
> perf_investigations  perf_opinions  perf_private_violence  perf_judicial_ind  perf_misconduct  perf_ba
> n_ideology  perf_legislature_check  ///
> perf_judiciary_check  perf_expand_executive  perf_candidates_disclose  perf_votes_impact  perf_foreign
>   perf_districts  ///
> perf_private_gain  perf_funds_transparent  perf_contributions  perf_common_und  perf_participation  pe
> rf_compromise  perf_patriotism  ///
>  [aw=weight], format(%5.2f) by(wave) col(statistics) la(25) var(25)

wave                      variable |      mean
-----------------------------------+----------
3              perf_election_fraud |      0.55
                      perf_protest |      0.60
                 perf_equal_rights |      0.51
                  perf_journalists |      0.55
            perf_monitor_opponents |      0.42
                  perf_free_speech |      0.63
                perf_voting_rights |      0.64
               perf_investigations |      0.33
                     perf_opinions |      0.59
             perf_private_violence |      0.35
                 perf_judicial_ind |      0.56
                   perf_misconduct |      0.33
                 perf_ban_ideology |      0.62
            perf_legislature_check |      0.49
              perf_judiciary_check |      0.59
             perf_expand_executive |      0.54
          perf_candidates_disclose |      0.52
                 perf_votes_impact |      0.51
                      perf_foreign |      0.42
                    perf_districts |      0.36
                 perf_private_gain |      0.24
            perf_funds_transparent |      0.35
                perf_contributions |      0.24
                   perf_common_und |      0.32
                perf_participation |      0.35
                   perf_compromise |      0.29
                   perf_patriotism |      0.23
-----------------------------------+----------
4              perf_election_fraud |      0.49
                      perf_protest |      0.55
                 perf_equal_rights |      0.45
                  perf_journalists |      0.39
            perf_monitor_opponents |      0.33
                  perf_free_speech |      0.50
                perf_voting_rights |      0.62
               perf_investigations |      0.25
                     perf_opinions |      0.49
             perf_private_violence |      0.31
                 perf_judicial_ind |      0.39
                   perf_misconduct |      0.26
                 perf_ban_ideology |      0.56
            perf_legislature_check |      0.42
              perf_judiciary_check |      0.51
             perf_expand_executive |      0.47
          perf_candidates_disclose |      0.42
                 perf_votes_impact |      0.41
                      perf_foreign |      0.35
                    perf_districts |      0.29
                 perf_private_gain |      0.19
            perf_funds_transparent |      0.32
                perf_contributions |      0.21
                   perf_common_und |      0.24
                perf_participation |      0.32
                   perf_compromise |      0.22
                   perf_patriotism |      0.21
-----------------------------------+----------
5              perf_election_fraud |      0.49
                      perf_protest |      0.59
                 perf_equal_rights |      0.41
                  perf_journalists |      0.39
            perf_monitor_opponents |      0.29
                  perf_free_speech |      0.52
                perf_voting_rights |      0.61
               perf_investigations |      0.23
                     perf_opinions |      0.50
             perf_private_violence |      0.30
                 perf_judicial_ind |      0.42
                   perf_misconduct |      0.25
                 perf_ban_ideology |      0.54
            perf_legislature_check |      0.43
              perf_judiciary_check |      0.49
             perf_expand_executive |      0.47
          perf_candidates_disclose |      0.44
                 perf_votes_impact |      0.44
                      perf_foreign |      0.35
                    perf_districts |      0.25
                 perf_private_gain |      0.17
            perf_funds_transparent |      0.33
                perf_contributions |      0.21
                   perf_common_und |      0.21
                perf_participation |      0.30
                   perf_compromise |      0.23
                   perf_patriotism |      0.14
-----------------------------------+----------
6              perf_election_fraud |      0.44
                      perf_protest |      0.55
                 perf_equal_rights |      0.38
                  perf_journalists |      0.37
            perf_monitor_opponents |      0.31
                  perf_free_speech |      0.48
                perf_voting_rights |      0.60
               perf_investigations |      0.26
                     perf_opinions |      0.51
             perf_private_violence |      0.28
                 perf_judicial_ind |      0.39
                   perf_misconduct |      0.25
                 perf_ban_ideology |      0.49
            perf_legislature_check |      0.43
              perf_judiciary_check |      0.45
             perf_expand_executive |      0.45
          perf_candidates_disclose |      0.46
                 perf_votes_impact |      0.41
                      perf_foreign |      0.34
                    perf_districts |      0.29
                 perf_private_gain |      0.16
            perf_funds_transparent |      0.31
                perf_contributions |      0.23
                   perf_common_und |      0.19
                perf_participation |      0.32
                   perf_compromise |      0.19
                   perf_patriotism |      0.16
-----------------------------------+----------
Total          perf_election_fraud |      0.49
                      perf_protest |      0.57
                 perf_equal_rights |      0.44
                  perf_journalists |      0.42
            perf_monitor_opponents |      0.34
                  perf_free_speech |      0.53
                perf_voting_rights |      0.62
               perf_investigations |      0.27
                     perf_opinions |      0.52
             perf_private_violence |      0.31
                 perf_judicial_ind |      0.44
                   perf_misconduct |      0.27
                 perf_ban_ideology |      0.55
            perf_legislature_check |      0.44
              perf_judiciary_check |      0.51
             perf_expand_executive |      0.48
          perf_candidates_disclose |      0.46
                 perf_votes_impact |      0.44
                      perf_foreign |      0.36
                    perf_districts |      0.30
                 perf_private_gain |      0.19
            perf_funds_transparent |      0.33
                perf_contributions |      0.22
                   perf_common_und |      0.24
                perf_participation |      0.32
                   perf_compromise |      0.23
                   perf_patriotism |      0.19
----------------------------------------------

. 
. * TRUMP SUPPORTER IMPORTANCE
. tabstat ///
> imp_election_fraud  imp_protest  imp_equal_rights  imp_journalists  imp_monitor_opponents  imp_free_sp
> eech  imp_voting_rights  ///
> imp_investigations  imp_opinions  imp_private_violence  imp_judicial_ind  imp_misconduct  imp_ban_ideo
> logy  imp_legislature_check  ///
> imp_judiciary_check  imp_expand_executive  imp_candidates_disclose  imp_votes_impact  imp_foreign_infl
> uence  imp_districts  ///
> imp_private_gain  imp_funds_transparent  imp_contributions  imp_common_und  imp_participation  imp_com
> promise  imp_patriotism  ///
>  if (wave==3 & trump==1) [aw=weight], format(%8.2f) col(statistics) la(25) var(25)

                 variable |      mean
--------------------------+----------
       imp_election_fraud |      0.87
              imp_protest |      0.77
         imp_equal_rights |      0.83
          imp_journalists |      0.65
    imp_monitor_opponents |      0.81
          imp_free_speech |      0.76
        imp_voting_rights |      0.85
       imp_investigations |      0.81
             imp_opinions |      0.81
     imp_private_violence |      0.65
         imp_judicial_ind |      0.76
           imp_misconduct |      0.81
         imp_ban_ideology |      0.77
    imp_legislature_check |      0.71
      imp_judiciary_check |      0.71
     imp_expand_executive |      0.81
  imp_candidates_disclose |      0.79
         imp_votes_impact |      0.78
    imp_foreign_influence |      0.74
            imp_districts |      0.66
         imp_private_gain |      0.79
    imp_funds_transparent |      0.68
        imp_contributions |      0.66
           imp_common_und |      0.71
        imp_participation |      0.72
           imp_compromise |      0.56
           imp_patriotism |      0.48
-------------------------------------

. 
. * TRUMP SUPPORTER PERFORMANCE
. tabstat ///
> perf_election_fraud  perf_protest  perf_equal_rights  perf_journalists  perf_monitor_opponents  perf_f
> ree_speech  perf_voting_rights  ///
> perf_investigations  perf_opinions  perf_private_violence  perf_judicial_ind  perf_misconduct  perf_ba
> n_ideology  perf_legislature_check  ///
> perf_judiciary_check  perf_expand_executive  perf_candidates_disclose  perf_votes_impact  perf_foreign
>   perf_districts  ///
> perf_private_gain  perf_funds_transparent  perf_contributions  perf_common_und  perf_participation  pe
> rf_compromise  perf_patriotism  ///
>  if (trump==1) [aw=weight], format(%5.2f) by(wave) col(statistics) la(25) var(25)

wave                      variable |      mean
-----------------------------------+----------
3              perf_election_fraud |      0.54
                      perf_protest |      0.63
                 perf_equal_rights |      0.68
                  perf_journalists |      0.63
            perf_monitor_opponents |      0.40
                  perf_free_speech |      0.61
                perf_voting_rights |      0.83
               perf_investigations |      0.40
                     perf_opinions |      0.62
             perf_private_violence |      0.37
                 perf_judicial_ind |      0.60
                   perf_misconduct |      0.37
                 perf_ban_ideology |      0.64
            perf_legislature_check |      0.54
              perf_judiciary_check |      0.63
             perf_expand_executive |      0.56
          perf_candidates_disclose |      0.58
                 perf_votes_impact |      0.63
                      perf_foreign |      0.67
                    perf_districts |      0.54
                 perf_private_gain |      0.31
            perf_funds_transparent |      0.40
                perf_contributions |      0.32
                   perf_common_und |      0.40
                perf_participation |      0.46
                   perf_compromise |      0.36
                   perf_patriotism |      0.27
-----------------------------------+----------
4              perf_election_fraud |      0.52
                      perf_protest |      0.66
                 perf_equal_rights |      0.62
                  perf_journalists |      0.56
            perf_monitor_opponents |      0.33
                  perf_free_speech |      0.53
                perf_voting_rights |      0.81
               perf_investigations |      0.27
                     perf_opinions |      0.51
             perf_private_violence |      0.32
                 perf_judicial_ind |      0.45
                   perf_misconduct |      0.31
                 perf_ban_ideology |      0.60
            perf_legislature_check |      0.52
              perf_judiciary_check |      0.61
             perf_expand_executive |      0.62
          perf_candidates_disclose |      0.53
                 perf_votes_impact |      0.56
                      perf_foreign |      0.53
                    perf_districts |      0.45
                 perf_private_gain |      0.25
            perf_funds_transparent |      0.40
                perf_contributions |      0.23
                   perf_common_und |      0.30
                perf_participation |      0.33
                   perf_compromise |      0.27
                   perf_patriotism |      0.23
-----------------------------------+----------
5              perf_election_fraud |      0.47
                      perf_protest |      0.65
                 perf_equal_rights |      0.55
                  perf_journalists |      0.47
            perf_monitor_opponents |      0.24
                  perf_free_speech |      0.50
                perf_voting_rights |      0.83
               perf_investigations |      0.22
                     perf_opinions |      0.50
             perf_private_violence |      0.29
                 perf_judicial_ind |      0.45
                   perf_misconduct |      0.25
                 perf_ban_ideology |      0.55
            perf_legislature_check |      0.57
              perf_judiciary_check |      0.58
             perf_expand_executive |      0.58
          perf_candidates_disclose |      0.48
                 perf_votes_impact |      0.55
                      perf_foreign |      0.54
                    perf_districts |      0.39
                 perf_private_gain |      0.17
            perf_funds_transparent |      0.37
                perf_contributions |      0.24
                   perf_common_und |      0.23
                perf_participation |      0.38
                   perf_compromise |      0.26
                   perf_patriotism |      0.18
-----------------------------------+----------
6              perf_election_fraud |      0.52
                      perf_protest |      0.68
                 perf_equal_rights |      0.55
                  perf_journalists |      0.51
            perf_monitor_opponents |      0.31
                  perf_free_speech |      0.51
                perf_voting_rights |      0.81
               perf_investigations |      0.28
                     perf_opinions |      0.59
             perf_private_violence |      0.27
                 perf_judicial_ind |      0.52
                   perf_misconduct |      0.31
                 perf_ban_ideology |      0.53
            perf_legislature_check |      0.60
              perf_judiciary_check |      0.61
             perf_expand_executive |      0.65
          perf_candidates_disclose |      0.53
                 perf_votes_impact |      0.57
                      perf_foreign |      0.56
                    perf_districts |      0.45
                 perf_private_gain |      0.19
            perf_funds_transparent |      0.43
                perf_contributions |      0.33
                   perf_common_und |      0.23
                perf_participation |      0.42
                   perf_compromise |      0.26
                   perf_patriotism |      0.22
-----------------------------------+----------
Total          perf_election_fraud |      0.51
                      perf_protest |      0.65
                 perf_equal_rights |      0.60
                  perf_journalists |      0.54
            perf_monitor_opponents |      0.32
                  perf_free_speech |      0.54
                perf_voting_rights |      0.82
               perf_investigations |      0.29
                     perf_opinions |      0.56
             perf_private_violence |      0.31
                 perf_judicial_ind |      0.50
                   perf_misconduct |      0.31
                 perf_ban_ideology |      0.58
            perf_legislature_check |      0.56
              perf_judiciary_check |      0.61
             perf_expand_executive |      0.60
          perf_candidates_disclose |      0.53
                 perf_votes_impact |      0.58
                      perf_foreign |      0.58
                    perf_districts |      0.46
                 perf_private_gain |      0.23
            perf_funds_transparent |      0.40
                perf_contributions |      0.28
                   perf_common_und |      0.29
                perf_participation |      0.40
                   perf_compromise |      0.29
                   perf_patriotism |      0.22
----------------------------------------------

. 
.  
.  * TRUMP OPPONBENT IMPORTANCE
. tabstat ///
> imp_election_fraud  imp_protest  imp_equal_rights  imp_journalists  imp_monitor_opponents  imp_free_sp
> eech  imp_voting_rights  ///
> imp_investigations  imp_opinions  imp_private_violence  imp_judicial_ind  imp_misconduct  imp_ban_ideo
> logy  imp_legislature_check  ///
> imp_judiciary_check  imp_expand_executive  imp_candidates_disclose  imp_votes_impact  imp_foreign_infl
> uence  imp_districts  ///
> imp_private_gain  imp_funds_transparent  imp_contributions  imp_common_und  imp_participation  imp_com
> promise  imp_patriotism  ///
>  if (wave==3 & trump==0) [aw=weight], format(%8.2f) col(statistics) la(25) var(25)

                 variable |      mean
--------------------------+----------
       imp_election_fraud |      0.93
              imp_protest |      0.85
         imp_equal_rights |      0.87
          imp_journalists |      0.80
    imp_monitor_opponents |      0.79
          imp_free_speech |      0.81
        imp_voting_rights |      0.91
       imp_investigations |      0.86
             imp_opinions |      0.84
     imp_private_violence |      0.71
         imp_judicial_ind |      0.86
           imp_misconduct |      0.86
         imp_ban_ideology |      0.81
    imp_legislature_check |      0.84
      imp_judiciary_check |      0.82
     imp_expand_executive |      0.84
  imp_candidates_disclose |      0.88
         imp_votes_impact |      0.85
    imp_foreign_influence |      0.90
            imp_districts |      0.79
         imp_private_gain |      0.83
    imp_funds_transparent |      0.75
        imp_contributions |      0.74
           imp_common_und |      0.79
        imp_participation |      0.75
           imp_compromise |      0.61
           imp_patriotism |      0.57
-------------------------------------

. 
. * TRUMP OPPONENT PERFORMANCE
. tabstat ///
> perf_election_fraud  perf_protest  perf_equal_rights  perf_journalists  perf_monitor_opponents  perf_f
> ree_speech  perf_voting_rights  ///
> perf_investigations  perf_opinions  perf_private_violence  perf_judicial_ind  perf_misconduct  perf_ba
> n_ideology  perf_legislature_check  ///
> perf_judiciary_check  perf_expand_executive  perf_candidates_disclose  perf_votes_impact  perf_foreign
>   perf_districts  ///
> perf_private_gain  perf_funds_transparent  perf_contributions  perf_common_und  perf_participation  pe
> rf_compromise  perf_patriotism  ///
>  if (trump==0) [aw=weight], format(%5.2f) by(wave) col(statistics) la(25) var(25)

wave                      variable |      mean
-----------------------------------+----------
3              perf_election_fraud |      0.55
                      perf_protest |      0.57
                 perf_equal_rights |      0.38
                  perf_journalists |      0.49
            perf_monitor_opponents |      0.43
                  perf_free_speech |      0.64
                perf_voting_rights |      0.52
               perf_investigations |      0.28
                     perf_opinions |      0.57
             perf_private_violence |      0.34
                 perf_judicial_ind |      0.53
                   perf_misconduct |      0.31
                 perf_ban_ideology |      0.61
            perf_legislature_check |      0.46
              perf_judiciary_check |      0.57
             perf_expand_executive |      0.52
          perf_candidates_disclose |      0.48
                 perf_votes_impact |      0.42
                      perf_foreign |      0.23
                    perf_districts |      0.22
                 perf_private_gain |      0.19
            perf_funds_transparent |      0.31
                perf_contributions |      0.18
                   perf_common_und |      0.26
                perf_participation |      0.26
                   perf_compromise |      0.24
                   perf_patriotism |      0.20
-----------------------------------+----------
4              perf_election_fraud |      0.47
                      perf_protest |      0.47
                 perf_equal_rights |      0.33
                  perf_journalists |      0.28
            perf_monitor_opponents |      0.34
                  perf_free_speech |      0.48
                perf_voting_rights |      0.50
               perf_investigations |      0.23
                     perf_opinions |      0.47
             perf_private_violence |      0.29
                 perf_judicial_ind |      0.36
                   perf_misconduct |      0.22
                 perf_ban_ideology |      0.53
            perf_legislature_check |      0.35
              perf_judiciary_check |      0.45
             perf_expand_executive |      0.37
          perf_candidates_disclose |      0.35
                 perf_votes_impact |      0.31
                      perf_foreign |      0.22
                    perf_districts |      0.19
                 perf_private_gain |      0.14
            perf_funds_transparent |      0.27
                perf_contributions |      0.20
                   perf_common_und |      0.20
                perf_participation |      0.31
                   perf_compromise |      0.18
                   perf_patriotism |      0.19
-----------------------------------+----------
5              perf_election_fraud |      0.50
                      perf_protest |      0.54
                 perf_equal_rights |      0.31
                  perf_journalists |      0.34
            perf_monitor_opponents |      0.32
                  perf_free_speech |      0.53
                perf_voting_rights |      0.46
               perf_investigations |      0.25
                     perf_opinions |      0.49
             perf_private_violence |      0.31
                 perf_judicial_ind |      0.39
                   perf_misconduct |      0.25
                 perf_ban_ideology |      0.53
            perf_legislature_check |      0.33
              perf_judiciary_check |      0.43
             perf_expand_executive |      0.38
          perf_candidates_disclose |      0.42
                 perf_votes_impact |      0.35
                      perf_foreign |      0.21
                    perf_districts |      0.14
                 perf_private_gain |      0.16
            perf_funds_transparent |      0.29
                perf_contributions |      0.19
                   perf_common_und |      0.20
                perf_participation |      0.24
                   perf_compromise |      0.20
                   perf_patriotism |      0.11
-----------------------------------+----------
6              perf_election_fraud |      0.36
                      perf_protest |      0.42
                 perf_equal_rights |      0.24
                  perf_journalists |      0.24
            perf_monitor_opponents |      0.30
                  perf_free_speech |      0.45
                perf_voting_rights |      0.41
               perf_investigations |      0.24
                     perf_opinions |      0.45
             perf_private_violence |      0.28
                 perf_judicial_ind |      0.28
                   perf_misconduct |      0.19
                 perf_ban_ideology |      0.46
            perf_legislature_check |      0.27
              perf_judiciary_check |      0.31
             perf_expand_executive |      0.28
          perf_candidates_disclose |      0.41
                 perf_votes_impact |      0.26
                      perf_foreign |      0.15
                    perf_districts |      0.13
                 perf_private_gain |      0.13
            perf_funds_transparent |      0.20
                perf_contributions |      0.14
                   perf_common_und |      0.14
                perf_participation |      0.23
                   perf_compromise |      0.14
                   perf_patriotism |      0.11
-----------------------------------+----------
Total          perf_election_fraud |      0.47
                      perf_protest |      0.50
                 perf_equal_rights |      0.32
                  perf_journalists |      0.34
            perf_monitor_opponents |      0.35
                  perf_free_speech |      0.53
                perf_voting_rights |      0.47
               perf_investigations |      0.25
                     perf_opinions |      0.49
             perf_private_violence |      0.31
                 perf_judicial_ind |      0.39
                   perf_misconduct |      0.24
                 perf_ban_ideology |      0.53
            perf_legislature_check |      0.35
              perf_judiciary_check |      0.44
             perf_expand_executive |      0.38
          perf_candidates_disclose |      0.41
                 perf_votes_impact |      0.33
                      perf_foreign |      0.20
                    perf_districts |      0.17
                 perf_private_gain |      0.16
            perf_funds_transparent |      0.27
                perf_contributions |      0.18
                   perf_common_und |      0.20
                perf_participation |      0.26
                   perf_compromise |      0.19
                   perf_patriotism |      0.15
----------------------------------------------

.  
.  
.  
.  
.  * READ EXPERT DATA
. clear

. use "Data/BLW_Expert_Waves123456.dta", clear
( )

. 
. tab wave

       wave |      Freq.     Percent        Cum.
------------+-----------------------------------
          1 |      1,569       24.40       24.40
          2 |      1,126       17.51       41.91
          3 |      1,055       16.41       58.32
          4 |      1,066       16.58       74.90
          5 |        935       14.54       89.44
          6 |        679       10.56      100.00
------------+-----------------------------------
      Total |      6,430      100.00

. 
. recode perf_misconduct-perf_investigations (1=0) (2=0) (3=1) (4=1) (5=.)
(perf_misconduct: 3952 changes made)
(perf_private_gain: 3921 changes made)
(perf_monitor_opponents: 3940 changes made)
(perf_equal_rights: 3990 changes made)
(perf_journalists: 3977 changes made)
(perf_private_violence: 3916 changes made)
(perf_free_speech: 3983 changes made)
(perf_patriotism: 4016 changes made)
(perf_foreign_influence: 3916 changes made)
(perf_ban_ideology: 3926 changes made)
(perf_voting_rights: 3968 changes made)
(perf_votes_impact: 3977 changes made)
(perf_election_fraud: 3957 changes made)
(perf_expand_executive: 3855 changes made)
(perf_legislature_check: 3921 changes made)
(perf_judiciary_check: 3924 changes made)
(perf_judicial_ind: 4021 changes made)
(perf_participation: 2450 changes made)
(perf_funds_transparent: 2468 changes made)
(perf_contributions: 2460 changes made)
(perf_opinions: 2426 changes made)
(perf_districts: 2449 changes made)
(perf_common_und: 2455 changes made)
(perf_compromise: 2459 changes made)
(perf_candidates_disclose: 2422 changes made)
(perf_protest: 2444 changes made)
(perf_investigations: 2376 changes made)

. label value perf_misconduct-perf_investigations statementlabel

. 
. recode imp_misconduct-imp_investigations (0=0) (1=0) (2=1) (3=1) 
(imp_misconduct: 2022 changes made)
(imp_private_gain: 1999 changes made)
(imp_monitor_opponents: 2032 changes made)
(imp_equal_rights: 2009 changes made)
(imp_journalists: 2013 changes made)
(imp_private_violence: 1994 changes made)
(imp_free_speech: 2024 changes made)
(imp_patriotism: 1861 changes made)
(imp_foreign_influence: 1979 changes made)
(imp_ban_ideology: 2024 changes made)
(imp_voting_rights: 2014 changes made)
(imp_votes_impact: 2005 changes made)
(imp_election_fraud: 2004 changes made)
(imp_expand_executive: 1980 changes made)
(imp_legislature_check: 1996 changes made)
(imp_judiciary_check: 1998 changes made)
(imp_judicial_ind: 502 changes made)
(imp_participation: 450 changes made)
(imp_funds_transparent: 473 changes made)
(imp_contributions: 434 changes made)
(imp_opinions: 468 changes made)
(imp_districts: 459 changes made)
(imp_common_und: 452 changes made)
(imp_compromise: 454 changes made)
(imp_candidates_disclose: 457 changes made)
(imp_protest: 471 changes made)
(imp_investigations: 457 changes made)

. label value imp_misconduct-imp_investigations statementlabel   

. 
. 
. * EXPERT IMPORTANCE
. tabstat ///
> imp_election_fraud  imp_protest  imp_equal_rights  imp_journalists  imp_monitor_opponents  imp_free_sp
> eech  imp_voting_rights  ///
> imp_investigations  imp_opinions  imp_private_violence  imp_judicial_ind  imp_misconduct  imp_ban_ideo
> logy  imp_legislature_check  ///
> imp_judiciary_check  imp_expand_executive  imp_candidates_disclose  imp_votes_impact  imp_foreign_infl
> uence  imp_districts  ///
> imp_private_gain  imp_funds_transparent  imp_contributions  imp_common_und  imp_participation  imp_com
> promise  imp_patriotism  ///
>  if wave==3, format(%5.2f) col(statistics) la(25) var(25)

                 variable |      mean
--------------------------+----------
       imp_election_fraud |      0.99
              imp_protest |      0.98
         imp_equal_rights |      0.98
          imp_journalists |      0.97
    imp_monitor_opponents |      0.97
          imp_free_speech |      0.97
        imp_voting_rights |      0.96
       imp_investigations |      0.94
             imp_opinions |      0.93
     imp_private_violence |      0.92
         imp_judicial_ind |      0.92
           imp_misconduct |      0.91
         imp_ban_ideology |      0.91
    imp_legislature_check |      0.89
      imp_judiciary_check |      0.88
     imp_expand_executive |      0.88
  imp_candidates_disclose |      0.86
         imp_votes_impact |      0.84
    imp_foreign_influence |      0.82
            imp_districts |      0.78
         imp_private_gain |      0.77
    imp_funds_transparent |      0.75
        imp_contributions |      0.71
           imp_common_und |      0.67
        imp_participation |      0.56
           imp_compromise |      0.50
           imp_patriotism |      0.46
-------------------------------------

. 
. * EXPERT PERFORMANCE
. tabstat ///
> perf_election_fraud  perf_protest  perf_equal_rights  perf_journalists  perf_monitor_opponents  perf_f
> ree_speech  perf_voting_rights  ///
> perf_investigations  perf_opinions  perf_private_violence  perf_judicial_ind  perf_misconduct  perf_ba
> n_ideology  perf_legislature_check  ///
> perf_judiciary_check  perf_expand_executive  perf_candidates_disclose  perf_votes_impact  perf_foreign
>   perf_districts  ///
> perf_private_gain  perf_funds_transparent  perf_contributions  perf_common_und  perf_participation  pe
> rf_compromise  perf_patriotism  ///
>  , format(%5.2f) by(wave) col(statistics) la(35) var(35)
(option varwidth() outside valid range 8..32; 32 assumed)
(option labelwidth() outside valid range 8..32; 32 assumed)

wave                             variable |      mean
------------------------------------------+----------
1                     perf_election_fraud |      0.88
                             perf_protest |         .
                        perf_equal_rights |      0.43
                         perf_journalists |      0.66
                   perf_monitor_opponents |      0.63
                         perf_free_speech |      0.82
                       perf_voting_rights |      0.37
                      perf_investigations |         .
                            perf_opinions |         .
                    perf_private_violence |      0.69
                        perf_judicial_ind |      0.65
                          perf_misconduct |      0.46
                        perf_ban_ideology |      0.85
                   perf_legislature_check |      0.53
                     perf_judiciary_check |      0.81
                    perf_expand_executive |      0.52
                 perf_candidates_disclose |         .
                        perf_votes_impact |      0.24
                   perf_foreign_influence |      0.46
                           perf_districts |         .
                        perf_private_gain |      0.28
                   perf_funds_transparent |         .
                       perf_contributions |         .
                          perf_common_und |         .
                       perf_participation |         .
                          perf_compromise |         .
                          perf_patriotism |      0.17
------------------------------------------+----------
2                     perf_election_fraud |      0.84
                             perf_protest |      0.81
                        perf_equal_rights |      0.34
                         perf_journalists |      0.63
                   perf_monitor_opponents |      0.64
                         perf_free_speech |      0.80
                       perf_voting_rights |      0.35
                      perf_investigations |      0.37
                            perf_opinions |      0.75
                    perf_private_violence |      0.69
                        perf_judicial_ind |      0.59
                          perf_misconduct |      0.45
                        perf_ban_ideology |      0.85
                   perf_legislature_check |      0.42
                     perf_judiciary_check |      0.77
                    perf_expand_executive |      0.40
                 perf_candidates_disclose |      0.68
                        perf_votes_impact |      0.24
                   perf_foreign_influence |      0.37
                           perf_districts |      0.07
                        perf_private_gain |      0.29
                   perf_funds_transparent |      0.34
                       perf_contributions |      0.17
                          perf_common_und |      0.10
                       perf_participation |      0.10
                          perf_compromise |      0.11
                          perf_patriotism |      0.19
------------------------------------------+----------
3                     perf_election_fraud |      0.84
                             perf_protest |      0.83
                        perf_equal_rights |      0.51
                         perf_journalists |      0.67
                   perf_monitor_opponents |      0.67
                         perf_free_speech |      0.85
                       perf_voting_rights |      0.47
                      perf_investigations |      0.52
                            perf_opinions |      0.77
                    perf_private_violence |      0.65
                        perf_judicial_ind |      0.76
                          perf_misconduct |      0.51
                        perf_ban_ideology |      0.87
                   perf_legislature_check |      0.58
                     perf_judiciary_check |      0.82
                    perf_expand_executive |      0.55
                 perf_candidates_disclose |      0.63
                        perf_votes_impact |      0.27
                   perf_foreign_influence |      0.40
                           perf_districts |      0.06
                        perf_private_gain |      0.33
                   perf_funds_transparent |      0.30
                       perf_contributions |      0.11
                          perf_common_und |      0.13
                       perf_participation |      0.09
                          perf_compromise |      0.07
                          perf_patriotism |      0.20
------------------------------------------+----------
4                     perf_election_fraud |      0.84
                             perf_protest |      0.74
                        perf_equal_rights |      0.36
                         perf_journalists |      0.61
                   perf_monitor_opponents |      0.55
                         perf_free_speech |      0.76
                       perf_voting_rights |      0.36
                      perf_investigations |      0.47
                            perf_opinions |      0.75
                    perf_private_violence |      0.67
                        perf_judicial_ind |      0.60
                          perf_misconduct |      0.44
                        perf_ban_ideology |      0.82
                   perf_legislature_check |      0.48
                     perf_judiciary_check |      0.74
                    perf_expand_executive |      0.46
                 perf_candidates_disclose |      0.67
                        perf_votes_impact |      0.27
                   perf_foreign_influence |      0.35
                           perf_districts |      0.08
                        perf_private_gain |      0.26
                   perf_funds_transparent |      0.35
                       perf_contributions |      0.17
                          perf_common_und |      0.12
                       perf_participation |      0.11
                          perf_compromise |      0.09
                          perf_patriotism |      0.14
------------------------------------------+----------
5                     perf_election_fraud |      0.83
                             perf_protest |      0.81
                        perf_equal_rights |      0.38
                         perf_journalists |      0.64
                   perf_monitor_opponents |      0.60
                         perf_free_speech |      0.80
                       perf_voting_rights |      0.45
                      perf_investigations |      0.49
                            perf_opinions |      0.71
                    perf_private_violence |      0.66
                        perf_judicial_ind |      0.61
                          perf_misconduct |      0.37
                        perf_ban_ideology |      0.84
                   perf_legislature_check |      0.40
                     perf_judiciary_check |      0.72
                    perf_expand_executive |      0.44
                 perf_candidates_disclose |      0.67
                        perf_votes_impact |      0.26
                   perf_foreign_influence |      0.36
                           perf_districts |      0.05
                        perf_private_gain |      0.30
                   perf_funds_transparent |      0.36
                       perf_contributions |      0.17
                          perf_common_und |      0.11
                       perf_participation |      0.10
                          perf_compromise |      0.11
                          perf_patriotism |      0.16
------------------------------------------+----------
6                     perf_election_fraud |      0.76
                             perf_protest |      0.83
                        perf_equal_rights |      0.38
                         perf_journalists |      0.58
                   perf_monitor_opponents |      0.60
                         perf_free_speech |      0.79
                       perf_voting_rights |      0.37
                      perf_investigations |      0.44
                            perf_opinions |      0.76
                    perf_private_violence |      0.60
                        perf_judicial_ind |      0.54
                          perf_misconduct |      0.35
                        perf_ban_ideology |      0.86
                   perf_legislature_check |      0.35
                     perf_judiciary_check |      0.57
                    perf_expand_executive |      0.34
                 perf_candidates_disclose |      0.67
                        perf_votes_impact |      0.23
                   perf_foreign_influence |      0.28
                           perf_districts |      0.07
                        perf_private_gain |      0.21
                   perf_funds_transparent |      0.31
                       perf_contributions |      0.12
                          perf_common_und |      0.08
                       perf_participation |      0.09
                          perf_compromise |      0.08
                          perf_patriotism |      0.10
------------------------------------------+----------
Total                 perf_election_fraud |      0.85
                             perf_protest |      0.80
                        perf_equal_rights |      0.41
                         perf_journalists |      0.64
                   perf_monitor_opponents |      0.62
                         perf_free_speech |      0.81
                       perf_voting_rights |      0.39
                      perf_investigations |      0.45
                            perf_opinions |      0.75
                    perf_private_violence |      0.67
                        perf_judicial_ind |      0.64
                          perf_misconduct |      0.44
                        perf_ban_ideology |      0.85
                   perf_legislature_check |      0.48
                     perf_judiciary_check |      0.77
                    perf_expand_executive |      0.47
                 perf_candidates_disclose |      0.67
                        perf_votes_impact |      0.25
                   perf_foreign_influence |      0.39
                           perf_districts |      0.07
                        perf_private_gain |      0.28
                   perf_funds_transparent |      0.34
                       perf_contributions |      0.15
                          perf_common_und |      0.11
                       perf_participation |      0.10
                          perf_compromise |      0.09
                          perf_patriotism |      0.16
-----------------------------------------------------

. 
.  log close
      name:  <unnamed>
       log:  C:\Users\mitch\Dropbox\BLW\POP\Searching for a Bright Line\Replication Materials\Logs/appen
> dix.log
  log type:  text
 closed on:   4 Dec 2018, 20:46:53
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
